Apple’s new Child Safety features ‘don't get to where the harm is happening,’ online safety expert says — pushing responsibility to i Phone app developers poses a ‘huge risk’ to kids despite ‘genuine progress’ | Tech Radar
Overview
News, deals, reviews, guides and more on the newest computing gadgets
Start exploring exclusive deals, expert advice and more
Details
Unlock and manage exclusive Techradar member rewards.
Unlock instant access to exclusive member features.
Get full access to premium articles, exclusive features and a growing list of member rewards.
Apple’s new Child Safety features ‘don't get to where the harm is happening,’ online safety expert says — pushing responsibility to i Phone app developers poses a ‘huge risk’ to kids despite ‘genuine progress’
Exclusive: Safe To Net CEO says Big Tech firms still aren't doing enough to protect children online, despite ‘genuine progress’ being made in recent months
When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Here’s how it works.
i Phones are overwhelmingly the most popular phones among teenagers (Image credit: Getty Images / Anna Barclay)
Online safety — and in particular, the online safety of children — has emerged as a hot topic of debate in recent months.
The UK is following Australia’s lead in banning social media for under-16s, while Big Tech companies including Apple and Google have committed to giving parents more safety tools to better protect their children from smartphone-related harm.
Apple, for its part, dedicated a sizeable portion of its WWDC 2026 presentation to the new Child Account features it’s introducing in i OS 27, but are these changes — which include more granular parental control and app-specific screen time limits — enough to satisfy increasingly safety-concerned governments? The answer, at least for now, appears to be ‘no’.
On the same day as Apple’s WWDC 2026 keynote, the UK government gave major tech firms a three-month ultimatum to “implement technical solutions on smartphones and tablets to detect and block nude images for children,” lest they face fines and legislative action forcing them to do so.
Keir Starmer speaking at London Tech Week 2026 (Image credit: Getty Images / WPA Pool / Pool)
UK Prime Minister Keir Starmer referenced Apple and Google by name as the biggest bearers of responsibility on this “horrific issue”, adding that “nothing is off the table” in terms of sanctions: “As a last resort, we are exploring criminal liability for tech bosses who fail to comply.” Yikes.
Here's the real reason Apple made a big deal of Screen Time and Child Safety at WWDC
A spy in your pocket? How the UK’s proposed on-device nude image blocking could work in reality
How Nex's kid-friendly console aims to be ahead of the UK's Online Safety Act
Starmer also cited British AI company Safe To Net — whose Harm Block software blocks all nude content on supported smartphones at the operating system (OS) level — as proof that the government’s demands are possible to implement at a technological level.
Tech Radar spoke exclusively to Richard Pursey, founder and CEO of Safe To Net, to understand where Big Tech companies like Apple are still falling short when it comes to child safety — and how they can address the vulnerabilities in their respective approaches to this complex issue.
The questions in this interview have been edited for clarity.
Tech Radar (TR): Apple dedicated a sizeable portion of its WWDC 2026 keynote to demonstrating its new child safety features. Does this suggest Big Tech companies are waking up to the dangers of smartphone use among children?
Richard Pursey (RP): All advancements from Big Tech in online child safety are welcome. At Safe To Net, we've never believed in one silver bullet, because protecting children online requires a collaborative approach where the online safety ecosystem must work together. This includes legislators, big tech, and cyber safety specialists like Safe To Net.
Australia's social media ban shows UK child safety measures are bound to fail — and it's not because of VPNs
5 new child safety features coming to Apple devices in i OS 27 — from Ask to Browse to Time Allowances
I've spent hours researching the best phone for my child — here are the safest options I've found, from i Phones to 'dumbphones'
What Apple announced at WWDC 2026 was genuine progress: mandatory child accounts, parental approval before new app downloads or website [visits], and an expansion of its Communication Safety detection to cover violent and graphic content alongside nudity. All of that matters, and parents should switch it on.
But the protection still lives where Apple chooses to build it — inside its own apps, like i Message and Face Time — and depends on individual app developers like Meta, Tik Tok, etc. choosing to build similar protections into theirs. And there’s the rub. The tech platforms have been given years to sort this issue out, and they’ve failed. I don’t see why they will start now. As welcome as Apple’s announcements are, they don’t get to where the harm is happening — on platforms where users can see, film and share harmful content.
Apple announced a slew of new Child Safety features at WWDC 2026 (Image credit: Apple)
Ann Thai, Apple’s Senior Director of Marketplace Platforms and Technologies, said at WWDC 2026, “It’s developers who play an important role in assuring kids get age-appropriate experiences in apps”. She further continues, “…we believe every app has the same responsibility.” And [she] cited Apple’s resources to help developers build this functionality into their apps. The reliance on every app platform, every messaging app, every chat room, [and] every gaming platform to build solutions themselves is a huge risk to every child's safety. We can’t afford to leave any gaps, as we all know that the bad actors will find them and exploit them.
The tech platforms have been given years to sort this issue out, and they’ve failed. Richard Pursey, CEO of Safe To Net
The tech platforms have been given years to sort this issue out, and they’ve failed.
That's precisely the gap that the UK government called out on June 8, giving every device manufacturer three months to define how they will close it.
It's also the gap Harm Block was built to close: one safeguarding layer that runs across the entire device. One that is application agnostic and which even works on E2EE environments. Harm Block is designed to prevent the seeing, filming, and sharing of sexual content across the entire device, including livestream and the camera. The government further stated that all of this must be delivered without threatening users’ privacy, which is where Harm Block is so powerful. It runs on the device, in real-time, without collecting or transmitting any user data.
Some studies suggest that up to 88% of US teenagers own an i Phone (Image credit: Getty Images)
TR: Is it too late — or even possible — for Big Tech companies to implement these changes?
RP: It's not too late, but we can’t be timid in our approach. The UK Government has been bold, and it must not soften or concede. Harm Block is absolute proof that it is possible to make every smartphone and tablet (laptops too — even though they are out of the initial UK Government scope) safe out of the box.
Technology like ours is tamper-proof; it cannot be deleted or circumvented. This must become the standard. We used to drive cars without seat belts. Nobody in their right mind would do that now. So, we need to push ahead with confidence and make every device in the hands of a child safe to use. We can do that, and we can do it now.
TR: Apple's Communication Safety feature uses on-device AI to determine if a photo or video appears to contain nudity and blocks that content accordingly. As you noted, Apple announced that it's expanding this functionality to include gore and violent content. Could you clarify how Harm Block still differs from Apple's approach?
RP: Harm Block is universal. It runs across every device and across the entirety of that device. It isn’t selective like Apple. It is agnostic and protects across the entire ecosystem — not just the apps a manufacturer happens to control. Harm Block stops problems like sextortion in its tracks because it works in the camera of any application — not just the Apple native camera. I don’t know of a single parent who doesn’t want that.
We can’t afford to leave any gaps, as we all know that the bad actors will find them and exploit them. Richard Pursey, CEO of Safe To Net
We can’t afford to leave any gaps, as we all know that the bad actors will find them and exploit them.
TR: Regarding the UK government’s new demands surrounding the detection of sexually explicit images, how does Apple’s current approach fall short of those demands?
RP: There's still a clear gap. Apple has confirmed it can block explicit content within its own messaging ecosystem, but it puts the responsibility on every other app to build that same protection into its own environment, and there's currently no way for a parent to check whether any given app has actually done that. The camera also remains unprotected, meaning content can be created.
With a Harm Block-enabled device, you don't have to check. It just works the moment the device is switched on. You'll see our sapling symbol in the status bar, and that's confirmation that nude-based protection is active across the entire device, not buried somewhere inside one app's settings. Children cannot circumvent or disable it. Parents shouldn't have to dig through every app their child has installed just to know their child is safe. Safe To Net makes the entire device safe out of the box. No onboarding, no confusing user flows. It just works.
The key features of Harm Block on the HMD Fuse (Image credit: Safe To Net)
TR: Are there plans to make Harm Block AI available on additional devices, beyond the HMD Fuse?
RP: Yes, and that is happening as we speak. More OEMs are turning to Safe To Net, including chipset manufacturers, and we plan to make some major announcements in that area very soon.
We believe we are setting the gold standard for on-device safety. If it isn’t Harm Block-enabled, then it isn’t safe. We are being chosen due to the speed, accuracy, and efficiency of our software, and, crucially, because we are independent. We are specialists in this area and have been safeguarding children for over 14 years. This is our area of expertise
Harm Block detects harm faster than the blink of an eye, which is how it works in livestream. Manufacturers like that we don’t intrude on the user’s experience of their device or their apps. We are chosen because we balance safety with privacy. We don’t know of anyone else who does that.
If Safe To Net is in talks with chipset manufacturers, it figures that Harm Block will become a key selling point of more phones soon — and hopefully on models available outside the UK, too.
Might the company also be in direct communication with Big Tech firms like Apple and Google over the issue of child safety? “I can't deny or confirm,” Safe To Net’s Co-Founder, Sharon Pursey, told Tech Radar for a separate article, which suggests Richard's vision for a true a “collaborative approach” might soon be realized.
In any case, if you’re mulling over which smartphone to buy your child right now, we recently researched the best phones for kids so you don’t have to. Our comprehensive guide explains the difference between smartphones, dumbphones, and hybrid devices, and features recommendations for different parental needs.
We've reached out to Apple for its response to the UK government's demands and will update this article if we hear back.
Follow Tech Radar on Google News and add us as a preferred source to get our expert news, reviews, and opinion in your feeds. Make sure to click the Follow button!
And of course you can also follow Tech Radar on Tik Tok for news, reviews, unboxings in video form, and get regular updates from us on Whats App too.
Axel is Tech Radar's Phones Editor, reporting on everything from the latest Apple developments to newest AI breakthroughs as part of the site's Mobile Computing vertical. Having previously written for publications including Esquire and Four Four Two, Axel is well-versed in the applications of technology beyond the desktop, and his coverage extends from general reporting and analysis to in-depth interviews and opinion.
Axel studied for a degree in English Literature at the University of Warwick before joining Tech Radar in 2020, where he earned an NCTJ qualification as part of the company’s inaugural digital training scheme.
You must confirm your public display name before commenting
1 How to watch Netherlands vs Sweden: Free Streams & TV Channels for FIFA World Cup 2026
2'This might actually force some actual brain cells to fire': Norway is banning younger school kids from using generative AI
3 Rivals season 2 star teases 'pretty full-on scenes' in November 2026 episodes — and fans need to be prepared for 'absolute madness' in these three
4 Watching the World Cup with friends? Here's which spilled pint will damage your phone the most — beware of cider!
5 The big Tech Radar Entertainment interview: Toy Story 5 VFX supervisor Thomas Jordan talks new toy designs, Easter eggs, Bonnie and Blaze, and Pixar's experiments with AI
Tech Radar is part of Future US Inc, an international media group and leading digital publisher. Visit our corporate site.
© Future US, Inc. Full 7th Floor, 130 West 42nd Street, New York, NY 10036.
Key Takeaways
- News, deals, reviews, guides and more on the newest computing gadgets
- Start exploring exclusive deals, expert advice and more
- Unlock and manage exclusive Techradar member rewards
- Unlock instant access to exclusive member features
- Get full access to premium articles, exclusive features and a growing list of member rewards
