Dutton Ranch fans are convinced Yellowstone spinoff has made a 'rookie mistake' in its devasting episode 4 storyline — and are still in shock over one 'needless death' | Tech Radar
Overview
News, deals, reviews, guides and more on the newest computing gadgets
Start exploring exclusive deals, expert advice and more
Details
Unlock and manage exclusive Techradar member rewards.
Unlock instant access to exclusive member features.
Get full access to premium articles, exclusive features and a growing list of member rewards.
Dutton Ranch fans are convinced Yellowstone spinoff has made a 'rookie mistake' in its devasting episode 4 storyline — and are still in shock over one 'needless death'
The argument of reality vs. creative license continues
When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Here’s how it works.
Annette Bening as Beulah. (Image credit: Paramount+)
We're only four episodes into new Yellowstone spinoff series Dutton Ranch, but Beth (Kelly Reilly) and Rip's (Cole Hauser) world is already falling from under their feet.
After the bull that the couple bought at the cattle auction turned out to be diseased, their entire cattle herd came down with cow foot and mouth disease.
From there, it was all hands on deck to shoot them all in episode 4, and dispose of them in a makeshift mass grave the size of an Olympic swimming pool. Yes, that was a grisly to watch as it is to read.
Dutton Ranch fans convinced Yellowstone spinoff's premiere has glaring plot hole
Dutton Ranch episode 4 recap: Yellowstone spinoff has bleakest franchise ending of all time
Dutton Ranch episode 3 recap: everything that happened this week in Yellowstone spinoff
Not only did fans find this (understandably upsetting), but an eagle-eyed few have noticed a "rookie mistake" that could have saved endless cattle lives if changed — including the cute yet terrified calf we see left standing right at the end.
Dutton Ranch fans think Beth and Rip's new bull should have been quarantined before being introduced to the herd
"I'm a little frustrated as someone who has grown up and raised livestock for a good majority of my life," one fan explains on Reddit.
"Wouldn't it have made more sense to quarantine that bull for the standard two weeks to a month before putting them in their herd? From a livestock standpoint... how the hell did they not even consider a quarantine period?"
They continue, "I feel like that was such a rookie mistake, even with falsified documents. I feel like Beth and Rip should've known a lot better, considering the fragility of their new operation and recuperating from the last. It doesn't make sense to me the decisions. Even the previous episode when they just put the bull in, I was wondering what the hell they were thinking".
"That little red cow broke my heart, and it seemed like such a needless death. I'm not really sure how this is progressing the plot, unless they plan on basically taking over 10 Petals. Just kind of alarming, disappointing, and its going to get tiring if they just keep losing the same thing every few episodes."
It's a damning takedown, but a noteworthy one. The disease outbreak has been the dramatic anchor of both episodes 3 and 4, giving rival rancher Beulah (Annette Bening) an effortless upper hand. Beth and Rip starting over in Rio Paloma was never going to be straightforward, and where Duttons are concerned, drama never slows down.
But the logic does stand that as seasoned ranchers, there's no way that this should have happened. Beth and Rip have shown time and time again that they can go into something new with all guns blazing and still be in total control. However, there's always the question of creative license.
Dutton Ranch episode 4 release date and time on Paramount+
Dutton Ranch fans hope this unhinged character doesn't survive season 1 of Yellowstone spinoff
Dutton Ranch episodes 1 and 2 premiere recap, including John Dutton Yellowstone legacy
"I think sometimes we put too much thought into these shows," another fan argues. "It’s all for the effects. They wanted the drama of Rip having to destroy the herd and beat up white underwear man along with blowing up his trailer, so we can get the iconic scene of Beth and Rip walking away from the trailer as it exploded. Nobody would watch a show about quarantining a cow for two weeks."
"Hitchcock said it well. There’s no terror in the bang, only in the anticipation of it," another weighs in.
Beth and Rip are likely being set up by 10 Petal ranch... otherwise why did Beulah pull out from bidding on the bull at the last-minute? It might not have been the best practice, but last week's cow cull is definitely leading to something much bigger.
Follow Tech Radar on Google News and add us as a preferred source to get our expert news, reviews, and opinion in your feeds.
Jasmine is a Streaming Staff Writer for Tech Radar, previously writing for outlets including Radio Times, Yahoo! and Stylist. She specialises in comfort TV shows and movies, ranging from Hallmark's latest tearjerker to Netflix's Virgin River. She's also the person who wrote an obituary for George Cooper Sr. during Young Sheldon Season 7 and still can't watch the funeral episode.
You must confirm your public display name before commenting
1 Dutton Ranch episode 4 devastating death has glaring storyline error say fans
2 Lego just expanded its retro collection with an iconic game console
4 Soft Bank offers €75 billion to help build Europe’s biggest data centre project
5 New Channel 4 drama Tip Toe is the best and most important TV show you'll watch all year
Tech Radar is part of Future US Inc, an international media group and leading digital publisher. Visit our corporate site.
© Future US, Inc. Full 7th Floor, 130 West 42nd Street, New York, NY 10036.
Key Takeaways
- News, deals, reviews, guides and more on the newest computing gadgets
- Start exploring exclusive deals, expert advice and more
- Unlock and manage exclusive Techradar member rewards
- Unlock instant access to exclusive member features
- Get full access to premium articles, exclusive features and a growing list of member rewards
