I finally sold my CD collection — and it reminded me why i Tunes was better than any streaming service in 2026 | Tech Radar

Overview

News, deals, reviews, guides and more on the newest smartphones

News, deals, reviews, guides and more on the newest computing gadgets

Details

Start exploring exclusive deals, expert advice and more

Unlock and manage exclusive Techradar member rewards.

I finally sold my CD collection — and it reminded me why i Tunes was better than any streaming service in 2026

It's not just nostalgia — ripping CDs was a real life lesson

When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Here’s how it works.

(Image credit: Getty Images / Houston Chronicle / Hearst Newspapers / Future)

Unlock instant access to exclusive member features.

Get full access to premium articles, exclusive features and a growing list of member rewards.

We're celebrating Apple's 50th birthday with a week of content about the tech giant. It covers everything from personal recollections from our writers to the greatest — and worst — Apple gadgets as voted by you, and you can read it all on our 50 years of Apple page.

With Apple celebrating its 50th anniversary this week, I've heard talk in music circles about what the brand's biggest contribution to audio has been over the past half a century.

Is it the Air Pods, which popularized wireless earbuds, or the classic Ear Pods which are still synonymous with the cheap earbuds you got in your phone's box? Maybe it's the Mac and it's Logic Pro and Garage Band apps, which has changed the tide for music pros, or conversely its killing of the smartphone headphone jack which pushed every other brand to follow suit?

That's not to mention El Classico: the i Pod, which I wrote about last year when I dusted mine off and gave it a spin. But to me there's one other Apple product which comes to mind when we're talking about the company's golden anniversary — and it's something I was reminded of when I recently sold by CD collection.

Finding 2026 a bit much already? You need a digital detox — and for me, a stack of cassette tapes is emphatically the way

How Apple accidentally destroyed the record business

I’ve used Macs in every decade since the 1980s and they still feel magical

It's something many have forgotten about or talk about in nostalgic tones, which is alarming to someone like me who still uses it. But it's dictated my views on tech and media to this day, and of course I'm talking about i Tunes.

What have we lost? In 2026, digital is still lower-quality than physical, eradicates the ritual and artistry of putting on a vinyl or enjoying a game's box art.

What have we lost? In 2026, digital is still lower-quality than physical, eradicates the ritual and artistry of putting on a vinyl or enjoying a game's box art.

i Tunes, for all you Gen Z-ers who haven't heard of it, is a media player and library created by Apple — yes, 'is', the company still lets you download and use i Tunes. It runs on Macs and Windows: no closed ecosystem here.

Released in January 2001 (five days after Runescape, and six days before Wikipedia, in a period of early internet history which was evidently formative for a young me), it let you buy music from its store or rip them from CDs.

You could then listen to them straight from the player or, if you owned an i Pod, sync them so your player had your library. It also offered podcasts, movies, books and, while i OS was in its formative years, apps.

No longer is i Tunes the default Apple media app, with the brand now stuffing its i Pods and i Phones with loads of different platforms instead of one simple one. And given that most media consumption is now streamed, and downloaded straight to our personal device, there's no arguing that i Tunes is mostly redundant. But what it taught me about media is still an important to my views.

I grew up when convenient music streaming was still just a twinkle in Spotify CEO Daniel Ek's eye; if you wanted to hear something and didn't want whatever junk was on the radio, you could either put on a You Tube music video (and I did create my fair share of playlists on there), or buy the CD.

I inherited an i Pod Classic from my mum, and didn't want to pay Apple's high fees on digital albums, so buying CDs was how I acquired all my music.

Samsung exec confirms Milk Music won't return — and for me, that's a mistake

Sonos' CEO reveals what's 'holding us back' from music streaming innovation

12 irresistibly boxy and beige retro Apple accessories

A chain of British media stores called HMV was my go-to retailer, offering two-for-£5 deals on many discs. I spent many an hour trawling through its collections, trying to find CDs by my favorite artists which came under this deal. Charity shops, the British version of a thrift store whose proceeds go to charity, were also great for £1 discs.

Over my teenhood I collected hundreds of CDs, to the tune of about 5,000 tracks; not a massive collection by audiophiles' standards, but a lot for a teen who'd only learnt to count that high recently.

I'd take these discs home, burn the disc to my computer using i Tunes, and sync my i Pod to have them on my handheld device.

It helped me see that physical and digital media wasn't a binary choice: you could have both, and that's been an important lesson I've kept with me ever since.

It helped me see that physical and digital media wasn't a binary choice: you could have both, and that's been an important lesson I've kept with me ever since.

I still remember the ritual well: monitoring the burn speeds to see how fast it'd go, manually adding the album artwork since i Tunes didn't do it automatically, and correcting any of the many metadata problems (one of many: if two artists contributed on a track, i Tunes would generally recognize the hyphenate as its own artist, rather than adding the track to either one of the artist's own menus).

Slowly over many years, I amassed this digital library of albums, which I could listen to on my i Pod or computer at my leisure, and this might seem a lot like music streaming but with extra steps. However, crucially, I still held onto the physical discs, and that's what makes all the difference.

Most people I know consume their media digitally. You'll stream music from Spotify, watch your movies on Netflix, buy your video games straight from Steam or the Play Station Store.

Physical discs have largely been offered up on the alter of convenience, except among diehard fans of the format. It seems especially true of younger people who've grown up with the convenience of streaming and, most crucially, can't afford to buy physical media.

But what have we lost? In 2026, digital is still lower-quality than physical, eradicates the ritual and artistry of putting on a vinyl or enjoying a game's box art, and usage of it puts you at the mercy of the ever-changing libraries of profit-focused companies.

You could probably guess from my previous discussion of CDs, that I'm a physical media boy. While the CDs recently had to go due to a house move, I still have quite a few physical PS4 games, a large DVD collection (and a single Blu Ray) and many, many books.

There's something about owning a shelf of films you can browse through, enjoying the tactile sensation of putting a disc in a drive, and actually owning the products I pay money for. I still long for the days of yore, when DVDs had plenty of special features and games had in-box maps.

I still remember the ritual well: monitoring the burn speeds to see how fast it'd go, manually adding the album artwork since i Tunes didn't do it automatically.

I still remember the ritual well: monitoring the burn speeds to see how fast it'd go, manually adding the album artwork since i Tunes didn't do it automatically.

Then there's the entire argument about media preservation. Some people treat movies that aren't on Netflix or Disney Plus as effectively nonexistent; I've had friends that have seriously suggested pirating movies that they want to watch, which aren't on Netflix. Yes, we had words after that. Suffice to say, digital media is a walled garden dictated by companies, and we can't trust companies with media preservation.

(And yes, I know that physical media isn't actually very good for media preservation; degradation means a DVD or CD won't last forever. But given how many films simply aren't available on any streaming service at all, it's better than nothing).

I know I'm not alone in this passion. I'm impressed by the frequent Blu Ray hauls Tech Radar's resident disc reviewer covers, and there are many people who swear off digital media entirely. But I'm a traitor to this cause too.

I'll admit, I stream content too: I use Spotify and Prime Video and the Epic Games Store. I still see some benefits of digital, even if I still want a library of physical ownership too. A weird combo? Not quite, and I think i Tunes is to blame.

As you'll remember, i Tunes left me with both a physical and digital library: I could enjoy the convenience of my songs on my computer or i Pod, but also had the discs themselves. If any accounts were broken or hacked, or my technology stopped working, I still owned the physical media and could simply use it again.

The same goes the other way: when I returned to my old CD collection a few months ago, in order to sell it, many of them just didn't work. Thankfully, I had the digital copies still!

Plus, I could pop the CDs into a player and listen to them out loud, without having to pair via Bluetooth or be connected to the internet and lose connection when the speakers randomly decide to connect to another phone.

i Tunes let me enjoy the best of both worlds, and so foster a nuanced view of the physical / digital media dichotomy. I still act on this to inform my buying decisions: I'll buy DVDs or Blu Rays of films I really like, so I have them to hand whenever I want and can display them on my shelf, but don't spend my own money on straight-to-streaming slop which isn't worth preserving.

I don't think this is intentionally what Apple was doing with i Tunes; it just wanted a simple media library which would push users into buying straight from the storefront. But during my formative years, it helped me see that physical and digital media wasn't a binary choice: you could have both, and that's been an important lesson I've kept with me ever since.

Follow Tech Radar on Google News and add us as a preferred source to get our expert news, reviews, and opinion in your feeds. Make sure to click the Follow button!

And of course you can also follow Tech Radar on Tik Tok for news, reviews, unboxings in video form, and get regular updates from us on Whats App too.

Tom Bedford is a freelance contributor covering tech, entertainment and gaming. Beyond Tech Radar, he has bylines on sites including Games Radar, Digital Trends, Android Police, Tech Advisor, Whatto Watch and BGR. From 2019 to 2022 he was on the Tech Radar team as the staff writer and then deputy editor for the mobile team.

You must confirm your public display name before commenting

1A new approach to navigation could reduce reliance on GPS

2 The Punisher: One Last Kill — release date, confirmed cast, and more about the Marvel TV Special on Disney+

3 Reddit is closing down its unfiltered r/all page of trending posts

4I hiked the highest peaks in Britain with a robotic exoskeleton

5I've driven the new Renault Twingo — and it's compact EV perfection

Tech Radar is part of Future US Inc, an international media group and leading digital publisher. Visit our corporate site.

© Future US, Inc. Full 7th Floor, 130 West 42nd Street, New York, NY 10036.

Key Takeaways

• News, deals, reviews, guides and more on the newest smartphones
• News, deals, reviews, guides and more on the newest computing gadgets
• Start exploring exclusive deals, expert advice and more
• Unlock and manage exclusive Techradar member rewards

• I finally sold my CD collection — and it reminded me why i Tunes was better than any streaming service in 2026