‘Our mind isn’t a dataset’ — as if Black Mirror taught us nothing at all, 33% of millennials and 25% of Gen Zers want to preserve themselves using AI | Tech Radar

Overview

‘Our mind isn’t a dataset’ — as if Black Mirror taught us nothing at all, 33% of millennials and 25% of Gen Zers want to preserve themselves using AI

When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Here’s how it works.

Details

Domhnall Gleeson and Hayley Atwell in Black Mirror (2011) (Image credit: Netflix)

You may be familiar with the classic Black Mirror episode Be Right Back, in which a young woman whose boyfriend is killed in a car accident decides to communicate with an artificial intelligence imitating him, eventually uploading his AI ‘brain’ into an android body that looks just like him.

As you’d expect from Black Mirror, things do not go quite to plan and end up somewhat horrifying, but that doesn’t seem to have stopped public interest in AI immortality from surging. According to Google Trends, searches for “AI immortality” have surged 2,426% over the past year and jumped 91% in the past month alone.

Now, a new Edu Brain survey of 3,000 people across three generations reveals that 1 in 3 millennials and 1 in 4 Gen Zers want to preserve themselves using AI after they’re gone, while their older peers remain skeptical – just 10% of Gen X are interested.

Meta could make social media posting immortal — and we should all cancel our Facebook accounts right now

What we lose when AI starts doing all our thinking at work

I’ve spent months tracking AI personalities and we’re reading it wrong

Gen Xers may be less keen on a digital afterlife, but they might not have a choice if they make their kids their next of kin. 27% of Gen Zers and 23% of millennials say they would want to immortalize their relatives. The idea that we might not have a choice about whether an AI version of ourselves lives on is particularly galling, especially to me, a Gen Xer.

“We’re already seeing early forms of digital personas – AI ‘deadbots’, grief simulators, digital twins and future-self models,” says Harry Southworth, Head of AI Development at Edu Brain. “They can mimic some aspects of human behavior based on extensive data, but they are far from fully encoding a human mind, as it’s shaped by lived empirical experience.”

While the idea of AI “immortality” is gaining traction, the reality of how close we are to achieving it is far less certain.

According to Nicky Zhu, an AI Interaction Product Manager at Dymesty, even the most advanced approaches, such as neural interfaces capable of recording patterns of brain activity, remain a long way off. Current research suggests the technology is still at least 15 to 25 years away, and even that only addresses part of the challenge. The deeper issues, Zhu argues, are far more fundamental.

Zhu outlines four major obstacles standing in the way of true digital resurrection — and they go well beyond simply building better AI models.

“Our mind isn’t a dataset. It is an enormous challenge to develop technology that can replicate memory and decision-making. I have developed conversational AI systems that have analyzed tens of thousands of user interaction data points. Yet, in more than 67% of cases, they still cannot predict rational human behavior. 94% of human memory and decision-making is based on unconscious, implicit, and automatic processes, while modern AI systems need to be provided with explicit, conscious data. As a result, ‘digital immortality’ services that build chatbots from text messages and social media posts don’t recreate a person; they generate simplified caricatures.”

Meta could make social media posting immortal — and we should all cancel our Facebook accounts right now

What we lose when AI starts doing all our thinking at work

I’ve spent months tracking AI personalities and we’re reading it wrong

Even if that hurdle could be overcome, Zhu points to a second concern: the growing commercialization of grief.

“AI representations of deceased loved ones create emotional dependence that companies can profit from; the average family pays $1,840 per year for chatbot subscriptions, according to recent market research. These predictive algorithms that provide statistically probable replies can prolong mourning, potentially harming families rather than providing comfort.”

“When sensitive data about people is stored in files, the risk of data breaches increases exponentially. Exposing the personality patterns, personal memories, and decision-making patterns of thousands of people will create opportunities for identity theft, behavioral manipulation, and fraud on a massive scale. Current tech and laws aren’t equipped to handle such complex issues.”

And finally, there’s the sheer scale of what would be required to accurately model a human being.

“We found that even fully specifying the decision preferences of one individual required at least 340 hours of interviews and behavioral tracking. Capturing someone’s broader cognitive architecture would likely require years or even decades of data collection. And storing one person’s full sensory data for just one day would require around 2.3 petabytes – more than most data centers can handle per individual, not to mention the massive energy demands.”

Taken together, these challenges paint a stark picture: while AI can already simulate fragments of a person, recreating a full human identity remains not just technically difficult, but conceptually unresolved.

Which leaves us in a strange place. The appetite for AI immortality is clearly growing, especially among younger generations, but the technology itself is still a long way from delivering anything close to the real thing.

For now, at least, what we’re being offered isn’t life after death, it’s something closer to a digital echo, and if Black Mirror taught us anything, it’s that it might not be the comfort people think it is.

Follow Tech Radar on Google News and add us as a preferred source to get our expert news, reviews, and opinion in your feeds. Make sure to click the Follow button!

And of course you can also follow Tech Radar on Tik Tok for news, reviews, unboxings in video form, and get regular updates from us on Whats App too.

Graham is the Senior Editor for AI at Tech Radar. With over 25 years of experience in both online and print journalism, Graham has worked for various market-leading tech brands including Computeractive, PC Pro, i More, Mac Format, Mac|Life, Maximum PC, and more. He specializes in reporting on everything to do with AI and has appeared on BBC TV shows like BBC One Breakfast and on Radio 4 commenting on the latest trends in tech. Graham has an honors degree in Computer Science and spends his spare time podcasting and blogging.

You must confirm your public display name before commenting

1 Developer says 'it'd be so cool if Bigfoot just came out and smashed my face' as the monster is added to Fallout 76

2'Caught in that tricky middle ground': Adobe highlights widening gap between consumers and businesses using agentic AI

3 Google takes down telecom hackers using Sheets and Saa S apps to spread mayhem

4 Don't believe the hype: That massive $1040 discount on this big-screen laptop isn't what it seems — but I found the creator laptops actually worth your money

5 Panasonic combined a portable TV with a CD player, and I can’t help being totally charmed by it

Tech Radar is part of Future US Inc, an international media group and leading digital publisher. Visit our corporate site.

© Future US, Inc. Full 7th Floor, 130 West 42nd Street, New York, NY 10036.

Key Takeaways

• ‘Our mind isn’t a dataset’ — as if Black Mirror taught us nothing at all, 33% of millennials and 25% of Gen Zers want to preserve themselves using AI

• When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission

• Domhnall Gleeson and Hayley Atwell in Black Mirror (2011) (Image credit: Netflix)

• You may be familiar with the classic Black Mirror episode Be Right Back, in which a young woman whose boyfriend is killed in a car accident decides to communicate with an artificial intelligence imitating him, eventually uploading his AI ‘brain’ into an android body that looks just like him

• As you’d expect from Black Mirror, things do not go quite to plan and end up somewhat horrifying, but that doesn’t seem to have stopped public interest in AI immortality from surging